Conversion Rate Optimization- Banners, Buttons, Text Links

click here imageClick through rates is one of the hottest topics for the business owner community today. While much has been written about it, marketers are still unsure as to what can serve as the proverbial ‘key to success’. Marketers today are willing to pull out all the stops to find answers to questions like:

  • How do call to actions play a role to increase conversion rate?
  • Is a button somehow more appealing than a text link?
  • Will banner advertising be obsolete in the next few years?

Answers to such questions and many others are revealed below. Read on.

Those striving to maintain a profitable business presence on the web are of the opinion that conversion exists in more than one form. Whether it is about getting clicks on a certain button/text links or the purchase of a product, at the end of the day, it is the action a visitor takes at your website that decides your business’ fate.

There is ample information on the web on how businesses can get the wheels going in the right direction by attracting more traffic. While some sing praises for Google referrals, others speak volumes of social networking sites that have secured success for countless brands overnight.

However, what about converting existing visitors for a website? One may find it hard to believe, but improving different aspects of your website is the little change that can make a big difference. In short, it can all boil down to doubling your income without doubling your traffic.

Banners- Aren’t they the Safest Bet?

Banners have been an amazing advertising strategy ever since affiliate websites and display advertising exists. However, many eye-brows have been raised in the last few years regarding their effectiveness. Many believe they should no longer be considered an option to gain additional traffic.

In order to test such claims, a test has been carried out with the assistance of the team at Live Casino. The test was endeavored at revealing how visitors react to the variety of conversion opportunities offered. In order to amass sufficient data to support our results, it is to be kept in mind that this test was carried for 12 months.


Out of the virtually countless websites available, was used as it already had the desired text links and conversion buttons in place. Also, the website makes use of banner advertising. In order to derive results, different software have been used to correlate data. The exercise attempts to reveal which are the banners that are clicked more and the most effective buttons that significantly improve conversion rates.

What’s clicked more?

In order to determine which promotional medium proved to be most effective, what we did was track clicks from different pages that landed visitors on this page and whether they made them through buttons, banners or text links. The click percentages for these three mediums are as follows.


As Google premier partners, we have an opportunity to try out new Alpha and Beta versions of various tools, that will be available to all advertisers at a later date, but we use these first.

Banners: 17%

Text link: 34%

Button: 43%

Banners Or Button/Text Links- What Works Best?

At the start, we were unsure about the results. However, it does seem that banners are losing their popularity with the passage of time. The sad part was that the rate of decline was steeper than expected.

As can be seen above, there is a banner placed prominently at the top of website. Also, there is a banner placed at the sidebar on the right. Despite the fact that these banners were so eminently placed, it came as a surprise that 83% of the click through rate was achieved through text links and buttons rather than the 17% which was attributed to banners.

While this was already a huge difference, what came as a further surprise was the increase of conversion rates by 4% in the next sixth months. This further manifests the idea that the potential of banners might actually be diminishing altogether. banner research

Banner Removal

Despite the fact that it was obvious that customers were inclined to use buttons and text links more, when all banners were removed, the click through rate swayed by 6%. This establishes that banners are still playing a role, irrespective of how insignificant they may be.

Text Links or Buttons

It was further found that green buttons on site, such as the ones at the bottom of the page and advertiser’s logo, resulted in a total of 43% clicks. The fact that text links contributed to 34% of the click through rate makes it obvious that there are a large number of individuals who read content in order to make well-informed decisions.

Context And Design- Do They Have An Influence?

When it comes to questions like if design and context has an effect on the click-through rate, we determined through this exercise which banners were more attractive than others and why. Let’s take a look at two examples.

Banner-Types: The Best Vs. The Worst

Worst case

Let’s take a look at the banner that generated only 4% click through rate. The casino business earns a decent amount of revenue, but apparently this banner did not have much to contribute to it.

worst case banner test

The reasons for this ineffectiveness were rather obvious. The colors are bleak. This is no call to action or obvious message. Half of the banner focused on branding that failed to stand out.

Best Case

best case ctr banner

This banner had the best results in terms of click through rates. The colors are eye-catching. There is a clear message that theirs is the finest casino in the world with a focus on compelling words. The call to action is highlighted using green color. Only 20% of the banner has been used for branding whereas the rest compliments the banner well.

Button Types- The Best vs. The Worst

Next we set out to finding out which buttons work best and if the aesthetics have any effect on the click through rate and this was our finding:

Worst Case

The red banners proved to be the worst as they generate a click through rate of only 29%.

red button banner

Best Case

The green ones proved to be the best as they generated a click through rate of 43%.

green button banner

As seen above, the red buttons proved to be less useful than green ones. This may have to do with mental association with the colors. Red means stop. Green, on the other hand, is perceived as an invitation to proceed. This warns you against using red buttons for any of your websites in future.

Text links

As stated before, the button’s color can serve as an important conversion factor. Now, we will take a look at what works for text links. Here contextual relevance comes into play. A link such as ‘Play Poker at William Hills Casino by Clicking Here’ is better than a link that says ‘Play Now’. The latter received 50% less stops. This implies that contextual relevance is of utmost importance in this scenario.

Bottom-line, buttons and text links work better than banners presumably because of trust and internet intelligence. Buttons/text links give out the signal that they will only land you on the desired location. Also, an average internet user has learned to ignore banner advertising ticking it off as forced third party advertising.

The above exercise backed up the belief that banners may no longer be as effective as they were once believed to be, but by achieving a balance in all the essential elements, banners can also be invaluable for a website. Just make sure that your banner has a clear message, appropriate amount of branding and a convincing call to action and you are all set to go.

The original experiment was first published at

Leave a Reply

Notify of

Recent posts

A Beginner’s Guide to Key Performance Indicators for Online Stores

April 19, 2019

Tracking and measuring online store key performance indicators is a critical component of any digital marketing campaign. High-quality web analytics helps to properly allocate your budget investments and stop investing in campaigns that don’t drive revenue. It enables you to measure whether the work you do delivers outcomes and if yes, then what the outcomes Continue reading >

How to Improve Sales Performance with Dashboards

April 17, 2019

Whatever ecommerce niche you work in, different types of dashboards may help you simplify evaluating the performance of your online marketing initiatives. These can be both independent platforms and supplementary services. For example, Facebook offers online businesses the opportunity to connect online and offline marketing channels for their ecommerce projects in the In-Store menu. In Continue reading >

Promodo Partners Ecommerce Export Conference — Istanbul, 2019

April 3, 2019

The ninth Promodo Partners conference was held on March 22nd in Istanbul, the largest city of Turkey. The decision to focus on e-export was due to a number of reasons. First of all, Turkey is the 4th largest export market in the EU, secondly, this vertical is extremely interesting for large-scale businesses, and thirdly, we Continue reading >

What Marketing Channels Were Effective For Different eCommerce Niches In 2018 (Part 2)

March 29, 2019

Although all marketing channels are aimed to help businesses attract new customers and retain existing buyers, the specifics of each particular niche effect the efficiency of each channel. Our findings in the CEE Ecommerce report can make it easier for retailers to understand how to allocate their marketing budget to receive better results within their Continue reading >

Let's get the ball rolling

Please fill in this short form and we will be in touch with you soon

For any questions [email protected]


+44 (0) 20 313 766 81
+44 7852 537715

The Terrace AT5,
Grantham Street,

+1 347 809 34 86

Las Vegas
7848 W. Sahara Ave.
NV 89117

State Of Ecommerce 2018 (Poland)

TOP 50 Market Players & Their Traffic Analysis

enter correct name, please
enter correct e-mail, please

Conversion Rate Optimization- Banners, Buttons, Text Links

start now

Start now